Reviews
Rating by month
| Month | Reviews | Average | Owner replies |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-10 | 7 | 4.71 | 0 |
| 2026-09 | 20 | 4.45 | 0 |
| 2026-08 | 22 | 4.41 | 0 |
| 2026-07 | 11 | 4.09 | 1 |
Latest reviews
Crazy good.
Delish!!
Didn’t know much about this place just decided to grab some pizza before a concert. Very big slices and good variety of choices. Don’t know if it’s the best in the city but not bad overall.
Decent shroom and cheese 🍕
Lunch Lady, Ruby, Pepperoni 🍕
A nice new York slice, crisped well on the bottom. I do think it needed a bit more salt though. Also, not the biggest fan of the olive oil drizzle added after the shredded Parmesan cheese.
UHH<br>MAZE<br>EEENNGGGG!!!<br>Amazing pizza and the ppl who work there 🙌
Best pizza I’ve ever had, but expensive though
This is my first time at Outta Sight, I wanted a snack and was in the area. Have heard this place is good, was not disappointed! Makeila helped me out, she recommended the Lunch Lady Special which was a deep dish style pizza. This place is more known for a thin crust I believe, but I prefer deep dish and the slice I got was tasty. I asked Makeila to fix it up however she would, she added hot honey drizzle, fresh basil, and parm - everything was so tasty! Love the food and service. It’s also super cool inside and affordable
The pizza was excellent, and the service was highly professional, with the pizza priced at six dollars.
Wow. NY style pizza in SF and it's extremely reasonably priced and spot on. So good.
Outta Sight Pizza? Yeah, I’d stay outta sight from this place.<br><br>The pizza itself is nothing life-changing. The presentation is beautiful, but looks are deceiving. The sauce leans sweet rather than tart, and while the dough is plush, the slice itself is surprisingly thin. And what people keep referring to as “charred” tasted, quite literally, burnt.<br><br>I asked for my pizza to go and got it wrapped in tinfoil. What am I doing, taking a plate home from Thanksgiving dinner at Grandma’s? Give me a classic pizza box.<br><br>Why this place has a cult following is beyond me. Eating this pizza felt like looking at a beautifully printed picture of food and then eating the paper it was printed on. Visually appealing, technically edible, on a soul level, it is unsatisfying. And I came here SEVERELY hungry.<br><br>Then there’s the ranch. You’re charging for ranch? That feels like charging for crushed red pepper flakes. A pepperoni slice and a side of ranch came out to about $7.50. Multiply that a few times and suddenly we’re approaching whole-pie money for something that didn’t even satisfy me.<br><br>That’s ultimately my problem with Outta Sight: it’s all presentation, no satisfying bite. Pretty slice, thin experience.<br><br>Not worth the hype. Not life-changing. And certainly not worth a cult following.<br><br>Outta Sight? Gladly.
Okay, surprisingly some of the best pizza I've had in SF!
Good American style pizza, but the meatball sub was the star
Delicious pizza and exceptional unique flavors/toppings such as the esquites slice I had that was served with a lime wedge.
Great mustaches great pizza!
Very good for takeout. The pizza does the job without being extraordinary. You can't really talk about atmosphere because I think it's clearly a takeout pizzeria.
