# Reviews Feature ID: `0x12d63300372f910b:0xd438ab25487d2c78` ## Rating Average 4.6/5 across the latest 20 reviews. | Stars | Reviews | | --- | --- | | 5 | 16 | | 4 | 1 | | 3 | 2 | | 2 | 1 | | 1 | 0 | The owner replied to 0% of these reviews. ## Rating by month | Month | Reviews | Average | Owner replies | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 2026-10 | 7 | 4.57 | 0 | | 2026-09 | 14 | 4.64 | 0 | | 2026-08 | 17 | 4.82 | 0 | | 2026-07 | 16 | 4.63 | 0 | | 2026-06 | 6 | 5.00 | 0 | ## Latest reviews ### Sa Da: 5.0/5, 3 weeks ago > Delicious from start to finish! ### Nina Andrich: 5.0/5, a month ago ### Mira Mettler: 5.0/5, a month ago > Small, manageable menu, but the food was simply incredible!\\We had the spaghetti allo scoglio and the pasta alla Norma – both dishes were super delicious and freshly prepared. Highly recommended! 2 photos attached. ### Stephan Strecker: 5.0/5, a month ago > Outstanding food—every single dish was fresh, authentic, and absolutely delicious! If you want to sit inside, reserving a table in advance is definitely a must, as it fills up quickly. Please note that the indoor area is extremely tight; bringing a dog makes it very cramped, so that is rather not recommended. A huge compliment goes to the lovely older lady taking care of the service: she was incredibly warm, welcoming, and attentive throughout. A fantastic culinary experience overall! 1 photo attached. ### PaMa: 5.0/5, a month ago > Friendly hosts, a charming little restaurant, and excellent food! They were actually fully booked that evening, but they made it possible for our family to eat there. The antipasti, pasta dishes, and desserts were all outstanding! Highly recommended! ### Schlucki: 5.0/5, a month ago > Delicious food, excellent service from the waiter. The tiramisu is highly recommended. ### Andrine Kastner: 2.0/5, a month ago > The food was truly excellent – ​​absolutely delicious, and there was nothing to criticize. Unfortunately, the service completely ruined the positive impression.\\By service, I specifically mean the bald waiter. We found his demeanor extremely unfriendly, rude, and at times downright insolent. What was particularly unpleasant was the impression that he was even less friendly and respectful towards foreign guests. Of course, we can't judge his motives, but that's exactly how his behavior came across to us.\\It's a shame, because the food definitely deserved a better rating. However, the service made the entire visit so unpleasant that we will seriously consider whether we will return. ### Liesbeth: 5.0/5, a month ago ### Cristina Parisini: 5.0/5, a month ago ### Mario Lugstein: 5.0/5, a month ago ### nico camporini: 5.0/5, a month ago ### marco gargani: 5.0/5, a month ago > I'm a top-notch chef on vacation on Elba. Gentlemen, this place is amazing. They cook better than me...it's crazy. Trust me, you won't find anything else. I ate bonito, which made me taste the sea. I'm a good one, but I couldn't make a meal like this. ### Fabio: 5.0/5, a month ago > A top restaurant on Elba, we were more than thrilled. The food, service, and ambiance were unbeatable – definitely worth a visit! 🫶🏼 2 photos attached. ### David Schmid: 5.0/5, a month ago > Great food, good portions and great service! ### Familie Wittmann: 3.0/5, 2 months ago > The food is truly excellent!\\Unfortunately, the waiter in question, with his pervasive, grumpy rudeness that is almost amusing at times, is a major drawback.\\A smile would only help him and the bad atmosphere he creates. ### Fabrizio Rossi: 4.0/5, 2 months ago > Excellent place in the center of Capoliveri, delicious dishes, friendly staff and Mirella is the number 1 in the place, I recommend it ### Giulia Quattrini: 5.0/5, 2 months ago > Rustic and well-decorated, it offers truly exquisite dishes.\Prices are reasonable. Many thanks to Mrs. Mirella for her hospitality.\We'll be back ❤️ ### Jessica Caroline: 5.0/5, 2 months ago > We had a wonderful evening, the food was delicious and Mrs. Mirella and her staff were very kind (: ### Noemi Agus: 3.0/5, 2 months ago > As soon as you enter Mirella's, you realize it's quite a unique place, but you appreciate it for what it is.\I was hesitant at first; there's no reservation number, so we went there very early to get a table, only to discover that they actually take reservations, and the tables outside were all booked "by word of mouth," which I don't think is fair.\The place is cramped, with cobwebs, dust, and a bathroom that's not very clean, in my opinion, but there are also paintings and cutting-edge vintage objects.\My companion had a carbonara that was a child's size (literally three forkfuls), I had a mussels with pepper, which unfortunately hadn't evaporated properly, and then I added a tagliolini with bottarga and clams, very good.\Dessert, the homemade tiramisu and chocolate and chili pepper cake, were delicious.\We met Mrs. Mirella, a capable 70-year-old woman who still dedicates herself as best she can to her restaurant, along with her assistants.\It was a bit of a strange experience but I would gladly go back. 1 photo attached. ### Giulia Barbato: 5.0/5, Edited 2 months ago > The best restaurant/osteria in the area, a fantastic atmosphere, and warm staff who make you feel at home.\The food is simply well-prepared, with love and passion. Divinely cooked fish, delicious homemade desserts—what more can I say? Try it because it's a guaranteed 10/10 value!\Mirella, the owner, is a sweetheart ♡ 6 photos attached.